Today's matchup
Casey is hosting Washington Nationals on the Tuesday, September 8, 2026 slate. He shows up on 6 boards — walks allowed (90.6/100, #3), outs recorded (60/100, #21), earned runs (39.9/100, #11), hits allowed (39.1/100, #11). We've got him at 1.3 on the walks allowed board. That's one of the stronger spots on the board today. Open any board row for the full breakdown of what's driving it.
Season line
22 starts, 5-9, 3.64 ERA, 1.12 WHIP, 113.2 innings. He's struck out 100 over that span, against 28 walks. This is the baseline the matchup adjusts from — the model starts here and then asks what the specific lineup he's facing does to strikeout arms, how the park plays, and how deep he's likely to go.
He throws right-handed
Casey throws right-handed, which is the ordinary case and means fewer wild swings in the lineup he faces. Opposing managers aren't restacking against him the way they would a left-hander, so his projection moves more on the quality of the lineup than on its handedness. What does move it: how deep he's been going lately, and whether the lineup in front of him strikes out.
His last 5 starts
Casey has 14 strikeouts in 23.7 innings across his last 5 starts, a 5.3 K/9, with a 4.56 ERA over that stretch and 6 walks. Strikeouts are the one pitcher market where our model has found real, graded room — projected workload and the specific lineup he draws move that number more than a season-long rate does. Start-by-start detail is in the log below.
Strikeouts and control
Casey has 100 strikeouts and 28 walks in 113.7 innings this season — 7.9 K/9 against 2.2 BB/9, a 3.6-to-1 ratio. That's strong control, and it does more for his projection than the raw strikeout number does. Walks are the fastest way to shorten a start — an arm that doesn't issue them gets deeper into games, which is what the outs and strikeout lines are really pricing.
What his floor looks like
Casey has made 22 starts this season, averaging 5.2 innings with a 3.64 ERA across them. In the 12 starts we hold detailed lines for, he got through five or more innings 8 times. That ratio is the honest read on his floor, and it's what separates an arm worth projecting on the outs board from one whose good starts are unpredictable enough that the market prices them better than we do.
How long he goes
Casey is averaging 4.5 innings a start across his last 8 outings, with a high of 6.0 and about 77 pitches a night. He's not going deep, and that caps the strikeout and outs projections no matter how good the matchup looks — you can't strike out hitters you don't face. Expected batters faced is one of the bigger inputs to his score for exactly this reason.
His best start in the log
Casey's high-water mark was Monday, June 29, 2026 at NYY: 10 strikeouts over 7.0 innings, 0 earned runs. One start doesn't set a projection — the model works off the blend of his recent work against the specific lineup in front of him — but it does show the ceiling when the matchup lines up.
Where he lands across our boards
Casey was scored on 6 boards in that matchup, and the spread is the interesting part: walks allowed graded 90.6/100 while fantasy points came in at 24.7/100. Same player, same game, same opposing arm — different questions. A spread that wide usually means the matchup favours one kind of outcome over another, and it's the clearest argument for reading the board that matches what you actually care about.
How the model reads him
Every arm on the slate goes through the same math, Casey included. Opposing lineup, handedness, expected batters faced, park, weather — weighted, combined, and normalized 0–100. We keep the weighting to ourselves and re-tune it weekly on real results. What we don't keep is the record: every projection here is graded against the box score at the line the market offered.
What we'd flag
Three caveats worth carrying. Not every player gets a posted line — book coverage runs to about 87% for confirmed starters, so a blank line is the market's silence, not ours. Lineup changes land late enough to strand a projection published hours earlier. And judging any of this on a single night is meaningless; the model is tuned on hundreds of settled outcomes.